Heathrow Protestors Taking Lessons from Second Life

Interesting to see that the protestors of the building of a third runway at Heathrow are aping the strategies used in Second Life.

By buying up property that would be required to build the new runway, taxiways, terminals and transport links (which makes it sound remarkably like a new airport altogether, just as BAA is being forced to sell other airports), and then splitting that property up into tiny lots that are sold to individuals, the goal must be to make the process of acquiring the land as hard as possible.

This sounds like the strategy used by many unscrupulous land merchants in Second Life – by buying up small plots of land (even a few square metres) and building huge (yet thin) garish structures, chock full of advertising and loud noises.The residents in the sleepy hollows have little choice to get a nice time in their game home, and sell up. Land barons gets a whole sim, at a low price, and start developing it with no interference.

Yes, the case here is people holding small plots to stop an expansion, the other way around, but the attempt to be an irritant and hope the other party goes away… well the success or failure of this is going to be visible over many many years.

So what do I think? Honestly I don’t know, because it’s impossible to measure the arguments – you’re going on other people’s best guesses and whatever baggage they bring to the runway. My personal experience of Heathrow is of the traveller, who invariably has to travel either T1 to T3 as a transfer, or more recently between T3 and T5. Is it any worse that Dallas Fort Worth or Chicago O’Hare?

What I think would make a bigger difference is a dedicated high speed rail line between Heathrow and Gatwick (and possibly Stanstead), solely for transfer passengers. Given you take up to 20 minutes to drive around Heathrow on a bus, a train transfer isn’t going to add that much, and opens up more runways and transfer passengers to the other airports

If BAA was getting to keep Gatwick, I’m sure this would happen…