Spaghetti, 168 mph fast balls, and the respect required for April Fool’s Day

Turns out that while the UK have the classic Panorama story of the Swiss Spaghetti Harvet for April Fools Day, America has Sidd Finch, a baseball pitcher who could throw the ball at 168 mph (most fast balls are between 90 and 100 mph, even in today’s game). And when you read the back story, just like Panorama, its appearance in Sports Illustrated, by a noted writer, sold the story, even though the clues about it being an April Fool were in plain site.

Maybe so but Sidd Finch was more than just another Sports Illustrated story. Readers, league officials, players, fans and the media believed, even if it was for a moment or a day, they believed that Finch was real.

“The quotes were all created and that’s why I think people believed it,” said Stewart. “When you get general managers, sports editors, they get Sports Illustrated and they pick up an article like that and they start skimming down, they’re looking for the Stottlemyre quote. That’s what the professional reader, the true baseball fan, are looking for.”

That’s what the internet has failed to grasp about APril First. It’s not about getting a quick PR buck, or a crazy idea and saying it’s a crazy idea. It’s about the long con, the manipulation of trust without damaging anyone, and about spinning a yarn so that everybody and nobody believes it at the same time. Not taking cheap shots at the competition.